This post will list out the CC used in the Gentleman's Club - Set #2, Lovely Ladies, and Fairy Royals.
Sorry for the delay to everyone who was waiting for this list. Since practically nothing is labeled in CAS what CC it is, it took me a while to figure out what was what.
I also realized that Darwin was not using the Frontbum skin for his face like I had thought (explained below), so if you downloaded that and were wondering why it still did not look the same as the photos, I've got it sorted out.
If you download the CC for at least the hair and skin, your Sims should look like mine. See below for info on Eye Contacts. Also, not every accessory used is listed since I couldn't find all of them (Karen/Sabrina's earrings), but it's pretty minor and you can easily replace them with something else you already have.
Because there are more items than I expected and to keep it all organized, the list can be found in the Google Docs spreadsheet below.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Aq8fYv4V_ZLLdEw3aFMtM3Y2ZHlzX2RUbUwwM0x2eWc&usp=sharing
A few things to note:
Thankfully, every piece of CC is non-default, meaning it won't overwrite skins, eyes, etc. of things you already have and mess with the way anything else in your game looks.
Darwin's skin was actually using Frontbum's body, but with Peggy Sims' face. Luckily, I was able to find a site that had converted the Peggy Sims into non-default versions. However, because the Sims were originally set to use a default/Frontbum skin, you will need to manually go in and change the skintones of Devon, Jason, Darwin, and Grantham to the Peggy skins (the shading bar in CAS will say Peggy on it). The package comes with three different skins - a dark/pale one, a yellow/tan one, and a more pink version. Devon, Jason, and Darwin use the pink version, while Grantham uses the yellow/tan version.
You really don't need to download all of the contacts from Burnt Waffles if you don't want to. I had used different ones to give some variety to them in photos. You can either download them all anyway, or just download the one you like the most, and manually go in and change everyone's eye colors to match the photos. Contacts are found under Looks > Makeup > Costume Makeup.
The clothing and accessories are also not required, but are still listed if you want the same look as the photos. I recommend at least getting Darwin and Grantham's outfits, just because they look so cool. ;)
Lastly, I'm not sure if I used different CC or if something else was off, but there are some things that aren't loading correctly from the original Exchange Sims even after I identified and redownloaded the CC to verify they were correct.
Cid - Long Sleeve Shirt as Accessory (change color to black) - this was for covering up his exposed stomach in his Everyday outfit
Darwin - Comeback Kid Tights (change color to black) - this was for covering up the gap between his pants and boots in his Formalwear outfit
Sabrina - Formal hair, listed under Hair With Accessories. There should be a group of 3 with the NewSea logo on each preview picture, the difference is the color of the clip. I chose the middle purple/blue version.